Why Nationalist Parties are So “Unpopular” in Ukraine?

It is commonly asserted by the Maidan supporting crowd that nationalist parties in Ukraine, like Svoboda and the Right Sector, do not score election victories, and therefore the accusation of there being a prevalent and socially accepting attitude towards radical nationalism is false. But they fail to mention the almost complete absence of ideological parties in Ukrainian top politics. And I have a theory of why this is?

Elections require a lot of money and electoral base, and this is even further accentuated in Ukraine, where the population is very poor and generally apathetic and distrustful towards politicians. The result of this is that the only parties represented in Ukrainian parliament are oligarch projects with an unclear ideology but good financial backing. Svoboda actually had some notable electoral support, and even won a majority on a regional level in Western Ukraine, and all this was when it was allegedly cultivated by the oligarchs before the Euromaidan. After the Maidan, in which Svoboda took active part, it became useless and embarrassing to the new regime, and quickly faded from top politics.

Parties such as Bloc of Petro Poroshenko, or Bloc of Yulia Tymoshenko, or Narodny Front, do not have a clearly defined ideology, and therefore can be filled with any ideological content the leaders see fit. It therefore begs a question of how much of radical nationalist ideology do these parties espouse. For instance, Poroshenko has been very actively promoting nationalist causes regarding the supremacy of the Ukrainian language, unification and independence of the Ukrainian Church, and promotion of symbols and “heroes” of Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA).

The problem of rehabilitation of radical nationalism in Ukraine should not be dismissed as a disinformation by red herrings like the electoral failures of a certain political party. Electoral success depends upon factors such as money and the size of membership, Ukrainian radical nationalist parties do not have either in abundance. However, that does not mean radical Ukrainian nationalism does not factor in Ukrainian society.

It Lacks Concentration Camps

Svidomites want Donbass back but without the people…

Mark Hordyenko is a “civic activist” from Odessa, leader of “Rada Hromadskoyi Bezpeky”, an organisation, whose major achievement appears to be collecting aid for Ukrainian soldiers fighting against Donbass people.

Here he is on 2 May 2014 on Kulikovo Pole:

IvrRTiG7HE8G_HYD67nGgwFaU2eQNlFLTzqO2UHm8GK_jDnJdJrJf5z5hI1XId1IXEguCQJDj8dA9hPHlopEzw.png

And below is his recent Facebook rant, which seems to have been removed by the admins, or by Hordyenko himself. Below the screen shot is my translation…

Screenshot 2018-11-04 at 10.59.59.png

Donbass is a cancerous tumour.

It always this way.

Crime, drinking miners, cult of the street and physical force.

When they tell us, that we need to return Donbass, give them a right to vote, pay billions of dollars for reconstruction, I understand this will not be a victory for Ukraine, it will be intoxication with the pitiful “Donbass does not sent empty wagons.”* Their whole world, poetry and dreams of the future are in this slogan.

They are cancer, and they hate us.

Should we liberate Donbass from the Russians? Yes we should.

But we cannot liberate the “people of Donbass” from themselves, so we have to stop saying the nonsense that they are also citizens of Ukraine. They are collaborators and traitors of Ukraine, and [they were] long before 2014.

Of course it is important to separate wheat from the chaff.

And defeated or liberated, they will hate us even more…

Screenshot 2018-11-04 at 22.57.43.png

My suggestion

If ever, the territory of DNR and LNR comes under our control. 20 of military-civic administration is instituted. Elections are banned. Akhmetov, and not Ukrainian budget will finance the needs of the region.

If we are to agree to the Minsk variety, -Ukraine will be taken over by Putin through “hear Donbass out.”

I can hear [Donbass] out but I can’t understand, accept, forgive. Only through repentance and penitence…

And in 20 years, they might be forgiven, if they wouldn’t be forgotten.

Mikheil Saakashvili to Ukrainians About Gas Prices

The former president of Georgia, and former governor of Odessa, Mikheil Saakashvili published this curious text on his Facebook page…

It was accompanied by this video, which I gave subtitles to…

Starting next month , Ukrainians will pay for gas and heating 24% more. They are trying to convince you that it is inevitable, otherwise Ukraine would not receive an IMF credit, and would not be able to pay her debts, and would need to announce a default.

I will tell you now, my dear Ukrainians, things that will not be very nice but I have to say them. Yes indeed, in the opposite case, Ukraine would default -because YOUR budget is being shamelessly stolen by everyone, who isn’t lazy to do it. Yes indeed, the price hike under such total robbery was inevitable. Moreover, another price hike is awaiting you and with it lowering of your already low quality of life. And this everything because you have accepted that the country is run by thieves and bandits -all those innumerable, jowly Poroshenkos, Hroysmans, Avakovs -and you are doing nothing to change it.

Do you think they are stealing from some abstract budget, they are stealing from some abstract state companies, and all this doesn’t have any relation to your family budget? But you are forgetting that the budget is financed by your money -taxpayers’ money. And when money is being stolen in such a way that there appear holes in the budget, there is only one way to shut these holes -at your expense.

If Russian oligarch Fuks wants to steal from Ukrainians, the thieves that you allow to run your country will allow him to do it (under the condition that he shares, of course) -and meanwhile your tickets for Kiev metro become more expensive. If Putin’s godfather Medvedchuk thinks he needs to again milk Ukrainians, SBU begins to to suppress all importers of liquified natural gas except for companies belonging to Medvedchuk, the gas price increases -and Ukrainians docilely pay. If it seems to this large pack of hungry parasites that runs Ukraine that they need money for a new Lexus, new yacht, or one more villa in Marbella -they will without shame use YOUR budget as their wallet. They will take what they need out of there -and then they will increase your gas and heating bills. And you again allow them to do this.

So if you are not against being constantly shaved (like sheep) -then why wouldn’t they use it to their advantage? That’s how hucksters, whom you (yes you!) allow to run your country think. And you will be shaved again and again.

When I was a president, I had dealings with the IMF. They care about a balanced budget, no matter how it will be achieved. If the patient drinks heavily, and he has a hole in the budget because of that, does not interest the IMF, how will the balanced budget appear, whether he will drink less, or his children will eat less. The second option is actually better because it is easier to implement.

It is the same with the state -the IMF can’t stop officials from stealing (or more precisely, it can ban it but cannot control the execution of this ban), therefore Ukrainians ought to eat less but pay more for gas and heating. Everything is that simple. Therefore, the first thing I did when I became president, I uprooted corruption, I ended the theft of the budged, and then I congratulated the IMF for their cooperation, and said that from now on, we don’t need their money (because we started to use our money better) and their “valuable” advice (because it is cannibalistic).

Therefore my dear Ukrainians, you alone are guilty for being milked by various trash. I know it is unpleasant to hear, I don’t find pleasure in telling you that. My heart bleeds when I these criminals bullying such a great nation. I, twice elected president by the people of Georgia, acknowledged as one of the best reformers in the World, was not ashamed to run on roofs and to live in a tend with a bucket instead of a toilet, so that they stop robbing you. If more people supported me back then, we would win. But many of you remained on the sides, and thought this doesn’t concern you.

You know, some people say problems in Ukraine should be solved by Ukrainians, not Georgians. I am fully in agreement with this. Until, you Ukrainians do not decide to stop criminals from robbing the country and the people -nothing will happen. You are being ruled by cowardly bastards, who will momentarily flee from the country, the moment you say “Enough!” But you are too patient. You are being governed by people who see “patient” as a synonym of “sufferer”. They consider your good will to be a weakness.

How much money do they have to steal from you, from your children, from your poor people. How many Lexus’ there needs to be bought instead of thermographic cameras for your soldiers, so that you stop suffering this? You are being taken for idiots, and you are being fed propaganda big boards with empty words about language, faith, and army (which is also being stolen from), which are being set up for money that has been stolen from you. And you continue being silent and are suffering this.

Maybe you are hoping that soon there will be elections and everything will change. Nothing will change unfortunately. Russian (ethnic, citizen?) Trukhanov will continue to rob the people of Odessa, and the management of Naftogaz will receive bonuses worth several millions because the incomes of Naftogaz have increased (why wouldn’t they increase, when you were made to pay more for gas?). Nothing will change if you tick the box next to another surname on the ballot. NOTH-ING. The new “tsar” will also think that he caught the bird of joy by the balls, that Ukraine is his to pillage for the next five years, local lords will bring bags with kickbacks to the same building, only for a different person, and members of parliament, who have joined new parties, will continue discussing in the hallways how best to bend you over.

Everything can change only if only you grow tired of playing the lottery that can’t be won at elections. You have to hold all your “servants” firmly by the balls, and you have rip them off from anyone the minute he thought to steal something from you. The new president decides to steal something in several months after election? Vote him out in a referendum*, do not allow him to steal for another 4 years and 10 months. When the Prosecutor Generals’ Office or the SBU extort businesses, instead of fighting against crime and corruption, kick the asses of the bosses of these organisations, sack them at a referendum and make them face justice. The mayor and the council of thieves are trading with public land in your town? Throw them out of power yourselves on a local referendum, cancel their criminal decisions, instead of blocking roads as the people of Zatoka are doing now. According to Ukrainian constitution, the only source of government’s power are you, the Ukrainian people.

This everything is realistically easy to achieve. But this will happen only when you say enough to tolerating this. When this happens, I, Ukrainian of Georgian origins, will happily help you with everything I can. But how long you will suffer this, depends on you alone.

And while you are think whether you ought to suffer a little bit more, please watch the video (above) about what your tolerance of this has already caused. Ukraine was overtaken by even Moldova in GDP per capita. Now Ukraine is the poorest country in Europe, without adding “after Moldova.” There is a new goal ahead -poorer than the countries of Africa. Fellows, please wake up earlier.

*I just recall that last time people demanded referendum in Odessa, they were burned alive by goons brought to the city by oligarchs.

More than 600,000 Ukrainian Optimists have Chosen Their European Future

Ukrainian president, Petro Poroshenko, or whoever writes his Twitter, is a joker..

Read this flowery tweet:

Screenshot 2018-11-01 at 02.25.42.png
Ukraine is a great potential of human power, great potential of human faith. Ukraine is a country of optimists with a unique faith in Europe and our own European future.

Eurostat confirms that more that 600,000 Ukrainian optimists have already decided to materialise their European future. I quote:

In 2017, citizens of Ukraine (662 000 beneficiaries, of which almost 88% in Poland) continued to receive the highest number of permits in the EU…

Hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians are also choosing a Russian future. Kommentarii.ua reports:

In the period between 2014-2016, 170,000 Ukrainian received Russian citizenship. 24,141 in 2014, 67,400 in 2015, and 75,497 in first nine month of 2016.

In 2017, 85,119 Ukrainians have received Russian citizenship, 67,022 have received a residency, 144,530 Ukrainians live in Russia based on residency documents.

Temporary residence permits were issued to 96,612 Ukrainians in 2017, in total 201,631 Ukrainians live in Russia with these documents.

Ukraine – What to Beware of?

I found this Russian translation from a Polish travel website Koniec Świata, and decided to translate it into English. I have used the Russian translation and checked with the Polish original, I found the Russian translation to be a bit mechanical and lacking. The Polish site original seems to have been edited by editors of the website, professional travellers, who are also listed there, and hence it could be first hand experience. The text refers mostly to mountain regions of Ukraine near the Polish border…

Attention citizens! Ukrainians have very strong heads. If you have enough common sense not to fraternise with whom ever in a bar, you will avoid many problems.

The tourist should not show off his favourite equipment, and then go alone into the mountains, there could be muggings.

Ukrainians are not famous for their punctuality, do not be surprised if the groom is late three hours to the wedding, or when a disco begins at ten, and people start gathering around midnight.

Rackets and scams: As everywhere, you should be be careful when exchanging currency outside of an [exchange] office or a bank because you don’t know the law, language and mentality.

In the bazaar, the price for foreigners is always higher, one ought to bargain.

The police likes to stretch the fines for invented road crimes. Never hold too much money in your wallet because if [the cops] see it, the price will only increase. You should not pay more than 20-50 hryvnia (for invented crimes).

When Ukrainian cops see a Polish registration plate, no matter if they have a good reason to stop the Pole or not, they will stop you. Ideally, without much talking give them few hryvnia. In the opposite case, they will direct you to the main office (which is an unequivocal suggestion).

Pay attention to “parking officials” at free parking places, who demand payment for parking. In this case, it is good to ask drivers near by if you really need to pay. If not, just ignore the “parking officer.”

Water: Do not drink tap water. In the mountains, only use flowing water in the creeks, not from lakes.

In mountains higher up one can drink out of wells and streams without worry. In the valleys, wells are usually shallow, and I do not recommend it, to children especially.

Water in rivers: bearing in mind that all the sewage from the high up flows through little streams into rivers, the coasts are densely populated, sewers are a fiction. I did not decide to swim in the Cheremosh. (several years ago there was a hepatitis epidemic) Water in the creeks is clean.

Food: Ukrainian food is hard to digest. In shops in small towns many food items are expired.

Attention:  The meat bought at the bazaar should be fried well. It may not have been tested.

Coffee and tea, if you don’t ask otherwise, will be sweetened.

You will have to wait long in restaurants because the cooks will clean potatoes or make pierogi specially for you -seriously, seriously. Also, do not read the menu in restaurants, and rather ask what they currently have.

Ukrainian meals have a lot of fat, salo in particular. Locals have no issue with this because they burn it during hard physical work but visitors may have problems with digestion.

Road traffic: The cops. They are able to stop you for anything and convince you of any crime, and would give you a choice to pay the fine on spot or to return to a nearest city to write a protocol, which can take several hours.

Other drivers – not having lights on in the dark, overtaking on the third (I quite did not understand what is meant here) is a Ukrainian norm.

Cows and other livestock – the way from the pastures to the pens often leads through a road, and you can land with your car in the middle of a heard.

The drivers drive without lights as long as they see things. Lights at night are often parking lights or some strange blue lights. Often they are missing one light or stop light.

When entering the roundabout turn on the left signal, (WTF? but that’s what it says) unless you are turning right right away. Most roundabout are an intersection of roads, the entering has a precedence. It does happen that Ukrainians drive into a roundabout against the flow.

On the roads we mind the road, pedestrians, animals, cyclists and above all other drivers, many of them bought their driving licenses, many are youngsters trying out their new car. Drivers of brand new models of most expensive cars are people you should avoid on the road.

A difficulty for a driver from Europe are cyclists without lights and pedestrians dressed in black clothing. I don’t speak about drunk drivers, those usually drive slowly.

Note: Traffic checks have been intensified recently, they get many drivers on the balloon. Also recently, extinguishers and first aid kits have become mandatory -the first trial continues.

Roadsigns are usually after intersections and are not repeated as long as you follow the main road.

Beware of pedestrians at crossings, they feel safe there, they enter the crossing without paying attention

If you see a stop sign and a policeman, stop before the sign and start driving when the policeman allows (if you register eye contact). If he does not pay attention to you, move slowly and continue. It is a road control, they do not check every car.

It is more convenient to pay the cops than write a protocol.

Nature: You can encounter wolves and bears in the meadows.

Illnesses: Because sanitary conditions in Ukraine are not always the best, it is good to get inoculated against hepatitis. It is also worth taking with you medicine against digestive ailments (stoperan, coal etc.). Medical services for foreigners are expensive and the equipment in hospitals leaves much to be desired.

Jaundice – it is worth to get vaccinated. Before the war, the region of Hutsulshchina were known for… venereal diseases. I don’t know how it is now, no friend bragged about it.

Vaccinations:

Hepatitis B – recommended (depending upon the nature of the stay)

Difficulties with transport around the country: Not enough public transport in small towns. Lack of punctuality, dismal condition of the roads (with the exception of the main ones).

In Ukraine there are unique roundabouts on which the main road is marked. On the roundabout, a driver must allow cars that come from the main road to pass. These roundabouts are preceded by a corresponding sign.

Road signs are often obscured by grass that overgrows them or by tree branches… In cities the road signs are much higher and you have to look out.

On huge sections of the road, there are no lines dividing the lanes, (probably it means that you can overtake), therefore a multilane road forms at wider roads depending on how many lanes the drivers want.

In cities, drivers park wherever they want, they force priority, exceed speed limit, and do not pay attention to pedestrians (who also do not care about walking on lanes). When they are upset they sound the horn.

Of course, holes on the roads (except for national roads). Watch out for suddenly appearing speed bumps, which you cannot expect, because Ukrainian drivers generally do not have the intention to slow down on them. I do not recommend taking a new car, or a car with hydraulics to Ukraine.

During rain, sections of the road which are not asphalted are very muddy.

The Times do not Favour Irredentism

In recent discussion on Anatoly Karlin’s blog, I realised how recuperating lost empires is just not in vogue…

Recovery of lost lands is just not very common in post-WWII world. I can think of the reunification of Germany, a second Albanian state in Kosovo, and the return of Crimea in my lifetime. In the post-WWII world, India waged a war against Portugal to seize Goa, Indonesia seized East Timor for a time, China seized Tibet, Turkey seized half of Cyprus but overall land grabs are simply rare.

In Europe we see reluctance of countries to retake what is rightfully theirs. As I already mentioned in one of my rants, Ukraine is reluctant to take back Donbass and Crimea. Not only does the pro-Western elite in Kiev not want the most pro-Russian regions back, they don’t want to assume the burden of rebuilding Donbass.

Russia chickened out of taking Novorossiya in 2014. It was clear Russia was not economically ready to make this move. One can only note at this instance that even the economic powerhouse, Germany, was unable to fully converge with its formerly socialist Eastern territories. Now Russia’s strategy vis-a-vis Ukraine is reduced to a pathetic song of federalisation, and unless Ukraine, or parts of Ukraine beyond LDNR and Crimea, are somehow brought back into Russia’s orbit, any thoughts of recuperating lost lands of the Rus’ are unrealistic.

Similarly, Romania’s idea of reuniting with the Republic of Moldova has been traded in for Romania’s NATO membership. Why take care of some Romanians in an estranged, piss poor country, when there are cushy seats in Brussels available right now. Irredentism in places like Germany or Italy is the domain of neo-nazi megalomaniacs, good luck with that.

But since Africans will always sell you their diamonds, control over a territory is not necessary. Far more important is controlling the people. I met more than one Moldovan with a Romanian passport. Ukrainians with Russian passports are also not uncommon. Ukraine is still in the process of trying to justify herself within the confines of her inheritance, the Ukrainian state. The only people dreaming about territorial conquest in Ukraine are radical nationalists, much like in Italy or Germany, so good luck with that.

Bulgarians Busted over Trading with Bulgarian Identity

There are people in Europe willing to pay for being Bulgarian. BBC reports…

More than 20 people have been arrested, including officials.

Applicants are said to have paid up to $5,690 (£4,445) for fake certificates of Bulgarian origin.

Police have raided the offices of the State Agency for Bulgarians Abroad.

Staff at the agency were allegedly involved in selling fake certificates to buyers in nearby non-EU countries.

Many of the false applications are believed to have come from states with sizeable ethnic Bulgarian minorities, including Moldova, Macedonia and Ukraine.

Some reports suggest the agency was issuing about 30 dubious certificates a week.

Prosecutors say they are investigating the agency’s work on counts including bribe-taking, forgery and abuse of office.

Conscious Polonisation and Derussification?

One common accusation of Russians against Ukrainian language is that it was artificially polonised, and made different from Russian to assume its uniqueness. I can think of at least two examples of this…

In Ukrainian town or city is called “misto”:

Screenshot 2018-10-28 at 15.33.15.png

Screenshot 2018-10-28 at 15.35.13.png

Towns and cities in Ukraine however bear the names Uzhhorod, a town in the extreme west of the country, Vyshhorod, in the suburbs of Kiev, and further east Myrhodod, in the Poltava region.

Each of these towns bear the Russian form “gorod”, “horod” in Ukrainian and South Russian pronunciation.

Screenshot 2018-10-28 at 15.45.45.png

The thing is, “misto” is a Western Slavic (compare Czech: “město”) form, that clearly entered the Ukrainian language through the Polish language, and it was likely consciously chosen to replace the Eastern Slavic form still apparent in the names of Ukrainian cities.

Screenshot 2018-10-28 at 16.02.41.png

Another such linguistic peculiarity concerns the hard sing. The hard sing is on old Slavic letter that at one point was overused. The Serbian language reformer,
Vuk Stefanović Karadžić famously wrote about the “Hardness of the hard sign”, and today the Serbian language lacks this letter altogether. The Russian language also dropped the hard sing following language reforms instituted by the bolsheviks, and now only uses it to mark a pause within a word. The Ukrainian language also dropped the hard sign, and now uses the apostrophe instead for the same function as the Russian language.

And I have to ask why? It is clear the Ukrainian language makers were aware of the hard sign. The apostrophe is a Late Medieval Western invention that has no tradition in Slavic languages. But it makes the Ukrainian language different from Russian, and that’s the point.

World Bank Predicts 100 Years of Ukraine’s Backwardness

Earlier this month, RIA reported the opinion of the World Bank Director for Belarus, Moldova, and Ukraine, Satu Kähkönen, who predicted a bleak century for Ukraine at the current rates of development…

If the current rates of development remain, Ukraine will need 100 years catch up with neighbouring European countries.

Kähkönen said that Kiev has not yet overcome results of the crisis of previous years.

“Income per capita is still lower than the same figures for 2014-2015” she said in an interview to Ekonomichna Prava.

According to Kähkönen, there is a risk reforms will be stopped, and may even be reversed because of [presidential] elections.

Head of Naftogaz Admited the Lack of Prospects for Ukraine

RIA reports…

Ukraine’s chances to become a leader in economic development are falling with a geometrical progression, and the country itself is a “failed case”, and cannot even be said to be in the middle. This is what the CEO of Naftogaz, Andrey Kobolev said to Novoe Vremya.

“If we remove emotions, we have a typical instance of a failed case. Not leaders, not in the middle. That is why the question of how to win in global competition becomes harder year after year.”

In his opinion, global leaders will develop very fast, which will attract qualified cadres into these countries. One of the most important factors will be the quality of human potential. Meanwhile, chances of Ukraine to become a global leader are falling with a geometrical progression, thinks the head of Naftogaz.